| 1 | Purdue University | West Lafayette |
| 2 | Indiana University Bloomington | Bloomington |
| 3 | University of Notre Dame | Notre Dame |
| 4 | Indiana University – Purdue University Indianapolis | Indianapolis |
| 5 | Ball State University | Muncie |
| 6 | Earlham College | Richmond |
| 7 | Indiana State University | Terre Haute |
| 8 | Hanover College | Hanover |
| 9 | DePauw University | Greencastle |
| 10 | University of Evansville | Evansville |
| 11 | Valparaiso University | Valparaíso |
| 12 | Butler University | Indianapolis |
| 13 | Purdue University Fort Wayne | Fort Wayne |
| 14 | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Terre Haute |
| 15 | University of Southern Indiana | Evansville |
| 16 | Wabash College | Crawfordsville |
| 17 | University of Indianapolis | Indianapolis |
| 18 | Goshen College | Goshen |
| 19 | Indiana Wesleyan University | Marion |
| 20 | Taylor University | Upland … |
| 21 | Indiana University South Bend | South Bend … |
| 22 | Indiana University Southeast | New Albany |
| 23 | Marian University | Indianapolis |
| 24 | Purdue University Northwest | Hammond |
| 25 | Saint Mary’s College | Notre Dame … |
| 26 | Vincennes University | Vincennes |
| 27 | Manchester University | North Manchester … |
| 28 | Anderson University, Indiana | Anderson … |
| 29 | Indiana University Northwest | Gary |
| 30 | Grace College | Winona Lake … |
| 31 | Trine University | Angola |
| 32 | Huntington University | Huntington … |
| 33 | Franklin College | Franklin |
| 34 | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Saint Mary of the Woods |
| 35 | Indiana Institute of Technology | Fort Wayne … |
| 36 | University of Saint Francis | Fort Wayne … |
| 37 | Bethel University | Mishawaka |
| 38 | Indiana University East | Richmond |
| 39 | Oakland City University | Oakland City |
| 40 | Calumet College of St. Joseph | Whiting |
| 41 | Holy Cross College | Notre Dame |
| 42 | Indiana University Kokomo | Kokomo |
| 43 | Martin University | Indianapolis |
| 44 | Indiana University Fort Wayne | Fort Wayne |
| |
